Chương 16: Chapter 13 — Parties Produce Data

One moment — Royal Road is checking your connection · ParallelGamer · 84 chương · ~61 phút đọc · Tạo 01/10/2026

Day Seventeen. Jack's first official interaction with the federal government had produced exactly what he should have expected. More paperwork. The message waiting in his inbox that morning contained no new Dungeon revelations, emergency summons, or classified photographs. The trial exchange was already underway; formal consulting terms and compensation were still being reviewed. The acknowledgment managed to make "we are working on it" occupy most of a page.

Jack read it once, archived it, and went back to breakfast. Of course it was under review. Everything was under review on Day Seventeen. His phone vibrated beside the plate. Hannah. Found two people for a party. Need a fourth. Cedar Run. Recommended 4-8. You busy? Jack looked at the message for several seconds. He had been meaning to run another public Dungeon eventually. Private Layer Four was better for loot and experience, but that had never been the only reason to enter a Dungeon. He typed back.

What Level are you now? The answer came almost immediately. 4 Jack nodded to himself. Good. Another message appeared. my weapon is better now too Jack considered his response. Better than the boots you bought instead of a weapon? There was a longer delay. i regret inviting you Jack smiled. What time? Cedar Run had changed faster than the road leading to it. The Gate itself stood in a fenced-off utility property on the edge of town, where old drainage infrastructure met newer concrete service buildings.

Seventeen days ago, a blue portal appearing there would have brought police barricades, television helicopters, and several hours of people asking whether reality had ended. Today, someone was selling coffee beside the parking lot. Not particularly good coffee. Still. Coffee. Temporary signs directed traffic toward overflow parking. An ambulance sat near the entrance beside two local police vehicles, while folding tables and pop-up tents had formed an irregular market around the safe perimeter.

LIFE FLASKS — $145 PORTAL SCROLLS — $95 F-RANK GEAR BOUGHT / SOLD FIRE RES / COLD RES / LIGHTNING RES — ASK FOR CURRENT STOCK A large hand-painted sign near the Gate read: NO FIREARMS INSIDE A second, smaller one beneath it: CARRY A PORTAL SCROLL Jack slowed as he walked past. Humanity was adapting. Messily, greedily, inconsistently, and with an impressive willingness to put up a cash-only beverage stand next to an interdimensional portal. But adapting. He found Hannah beside the LFG board.

She no longer had cardboard. That alone represented progress. Her current sign had been written on a cheap dry-erase board and contained actual useful information. LEVEL 4 — JOBLESS MELEE / HEAVY STRIKE FIRE / COLD / LIGHTNING RES LIFE FLASK PORTAL SCROLL CAN HANDLE ADDS LOOKING FOR F-RANK PARTY Jack stopped in front of it.

"Much better." Hannah looked up.

"I know."

"No cardboard."

"I retired the cardboard."

"Good."

"It served with honor."

"It embarrassed both of us."

"It got me a party."

"It got you me."

"Exactly." Jack decided not to continue down that particular logical path. Instead, he looked at her equipment. The cheap Dungeon boots she had bought at Greenvale were still there. Of course they were. The weapon was new, though. A better-made one-handed mace had replaced the cheap beginner weapon she had used in Greenvale. The rest of her gear was still a mixture of early Dungeon drops, affordable purchases, and whatever had been available in the right size. The Orchard Charm remained around her neck.

Jack focused briefly. Level Four, Jobless, with the same balanced spread of twenty Strength, twenty Dexterity, and twenty Intelligence. Three nearby Resistance Passives were active now: Fire, Cold, and Lightning, all eighteen percent. Jack nodded.

"All three?"

"All three."

"Good." Hannah blinked.

"You say that like I passed a test."

"You did." She stared at him for a moment, then frowned.

"You could sound happier about it."

"I said good."

"Exactly." Jack ignored that. The third Resistance node was the correct choice. He had already told her Lightning was probably next after she spent her remaining Level Three point on Cold, and Level Four had supplied the point she needed. The nearby Jewel Sockets were far more interesting in the long term, but interesting did not make them useful when Hannah possessed exactly zero Jewels and nobody Jack trusted had publicly verified a Jewel drop yet.

A socket without something to put inside it was just a hole in the Passive Tree. Hannah had followed the boring path. Excellent. She pointed behind him.

"Those are the other two." Two people approached from the market. The first was a woman somewhere in her mid-twenties, dressed in light Dungeon gear with twin short blades at her hips. Her movements had the slightly altered balance of someone whose Dexterity had already moved beyond ordinary human baseline. The second was a man closer to thirty carrying a staff with a pale blue crystal set near the head.

His equipment leaned heavily toward cloth, leather, and several pieces Jack recognized as Intelligence-oriented Energy Shield bases. Hannah made the introductions.

"Maya Ortiz. Rogue." Maya lifted a hand.

"Level Five."

"And this is Eli Carter. Mage," Hannah continued. Eli nodded.

"Also Five." Then both of them looked at Jack. Maya asked the obvious question.

"Level?"

"Seven." Silence. Not long. Long enough.

"Seriously?"

"Yes." Maya looked at Hannah.

"So he's carrying us."

"No," Jack said. Hannah sighed.

"He says things like that."

"I'm here to keep the party functional." Maya nodded slowly.

"That's carrying with management vocabulary."

"No." Hannah pointed at Jack.

"See?" Jack looked at her.

"You invited me."

"I am reconsidering several decisions." Maya laughed.

"How do you two know each other?" Hannah answered before Jack could.

"He found me holding a terrible sign and decided my life choices offended him."

"The sign offended me."

"Then he made me buy a Skill Gem."

"You needed one."

"Then a Life Flask."

"You needed that too."

"Then he insulted my boots." Jack looked down.

"Your boots remain indefensible." Maya laughed harder. Hannah folded her arms.

"Basically, he's my extremely judgmental Dungeon mentor." Jack paused. Mentor. That was not entirely inaccurate. He had taught her how to build, helped her level, corrected her equipment priorities, explained her Job, and repeatedly instructed her not to die. He could live with mentor.

"I'll accept mentor." Hannah narrowed her eyes.

"Not the judgmental part?"

"That was accurate." They moved toward the Gate. Jack did not announce himself as party leader. Nobody else did either. Then all three looked at him. Of course.

"Flasks?" Four Life Flasks appeared. Eli also had a Mana Flask occupying another slot.

"Portal Scrolls?" Four Scrolls. Jack looked over them once. Day One had featured people entering Dungeons with kitchen knives, firearms that barely worked, no escape option, and the general confidence of someone about to become a cautionary tale. Day Seventeen had four people standing beside an F-rank Gate with Skills, Flasks, Scrolls, and actual defensive equipment. That was improvement.

"Any Skill that moves enemies?" Hannah raised one hand.

"Heavy Strike."

"Anything else?" Maya shook her head.

"Flurry doesn't." Eli said, "Frost Bolt can Chill. No knockback that I've seen."

"Good. Anybody using a new Skill or new piece of equipment for the first time?" Three heads shook.

"Excellent." Maya looked amused.

"You ask that like somebody has answered yes."

"People answer yes." Hannah nodded solemnly.

"He's seen things."

"Unfortunately." Maya touched one of her daggers.

"Since we're doing introductions properly—Flurry. Fast repeated strikes. I built mostly Evasion."

"How much?"

"My sheet estimates seventy-two percent against comparable enemies." Good. Very good, actually. Jack looked at Eli.

"Frost Bolt. Energy Shield?"

"Mostly."

"How much experience with it?"

"Enough to know getting hit interrupts recharge." That answer was technically correct. Jack filed away the technically. Hannah adjusted the grip on her mace.

"Can we go before he starts giving us homework?" Jack stepped toward the Gate.

"You already have homework."

"I knew it." The blue surface accepted them. Cedar Run was wet. That was the first useful description. The second was industrial. They emerged onto a broad concrete-like service walkway running beside a shallow channel of dark water. Metal rails followed the edge, drainage pipes disappeared into walls that looked poured rather than carved, and dim System light reflected from patches of pale fungus growing around the ceiling. It resembled an enormous underground stormwater facility. It was not one.

No human construction crew had built it. No municipality had plans for it. The Dungeon had simply decided that a network of tunnels, culverts, reservoirs, and service platforms was the shape it wanted to wear. Jack had seen stranger things. He started forward. The first monsters found them before the first major intersection. Three rats. Not ordinary rats. Each was the size of a medium dog, with dark wet fur and teeth long enough to make the comparison mostly academic. Jack focused.

DRAIN RAT Level: 4 Rank: F Damage: Physical Secondary Effect: Minor Poison Three. Simple. Jack stepped forward. Cleave. A red arc followed the greataxe through the first pair. The third lunged. He shifted, brought the haft across to knock its bite off-line, then buried the greataxe head into its shoulder with a short conventional strike. The entire encounter lasted several seconds. Silence returned. Jack looked at the bodies. Then at the party. Maya was staring at him.

"Was that the plan?" Jack paused. Hannah folded her arms.

"You said you weren't carrying us."

"Adjustment."

"That's not an apology."

"Correct." Jack looked down the tunnel. Right. He had entered the Dungeon and immediately defaulted to efficient farming. That was useful if he wanted Experience. It was useless if he wanted information. The next group would be different.

"New plan." Maya grinned.

"So the first plan was bad."

"The first execution was too efficient." Hannah looked at Eli.

"He does this."

"I've noticed." Jack ignored both of them. He pointed.

"I take center if something needs holding. Hannah covers anything that gets through or breaks off. Maya, flank and priority targets. Eli, stay behind whoever currently has space." Maya raised an eyebrow.

"So Warrior, Rogue, Mage."

"No."

"Those are literally our Jobs."

"Jobs aren't roles. Your Job tells me what tools you're likely to have. It doesn't tell me what you need to do in the next ten seconds." Hannah nodded.

"Don't start an argument. We'll be here all day." Jack looked at her.

"Good advice."

"See? Growth." They moved. The next encounter gave Jack what he wanted. Two Drain Rats came from the front. Something else dropped from a pipe opening above them. SLUDGE HOPPER Level: 5 Rank: F Damage: Physical / Poison Mobility: High The creature looked like an amphibian that had been left too long in toxic water. Thick hind legs folded beneath a mottled body, and its mouth opened far wider than anything with that skull shape should have allowed. This narrative has been purloined without the author's approval.

Report any appearances on Amazon. Maya moved first. Fast. Very fast for a Level Five beginner. The first Rat snapped at her. Miss. She cut across its side. The Hopper launched itself. Miss. Maya pivoted and drove Flurry into the Rat. A rapid sequence of dagger strikes. Good. Another bite. Miss. Maya smiled.

"Seventy-two percent." Jack watched the spacing.

"Keep moving."

"I am moving." Technically. She was moving around the same six feet of floor because that was where the enemy she wanted to kill happened to be. A third Drain Rat emerged from behind a support column. Maya did not disengage. First attack. Miss. Second. Miss. The Hopper landed behind her. Three directions. Another bite came through. Hit. Maya jerked. The Hopper attacked immediately afterward. Jack moved. One Cleave took the third Rat out of the pressure pattern.

"Hannah."

"Got it." Hannah intercepted the second. Maya finally broke away instead of trying to finish the first target. The fight ended a few moments later. Maya checked her Life, then looked at Jack.

"Okay." She breathed out.

"That stopped feeling like seventy-two percent."

"Because it wasn't."

"I know repeated attacks reduce effective Evasion."

"You knew the sentence." Maya looked at him. Jack pointed toward the space she had occupied.

"You didn't change what you were doing." Her expression shifted. Not offended. Thinking.

"So the number wasn't the defense."

"It was part of it."

"And movement keeps the attack pressure low enough for the number to matter."

"Better." Hannah looked between them.

"Was that another test?"

"No." Maya wiped one dagger clean.

"It felt like one." Jack ignored that too. He had written about Evasion. People had read it. Maya clearly had. The problem was not missing information. The problem was the gap between understanding a sentence and changing behavior under pressure. Interesting. The Rustback Beetle arrived two rooms later. It was roughly the size of a dining table, with layered brown plates covering most of its body and six heavy legs that made the metal walkway vibrate.

RUSTBACK BEETLE Level: 6 Rank: F Damage: Physical Armor: High Mobility: Low"Slow," Jack said. Maya looked at the shell.

"Also ugly."

"That too." Eli raised his staff. Frost Bolt formed as a pale sphere near the crystal, then launched with a sharp pulse of cold. It struck the Beetle's front plating. Frost spread across one side. The creature slowed. Maya's first dagger strike scraped across the shell and barely bit. She frowned.

"Armor?"

"High."

"Helpful."

"Joints." She changed angle immediately, slipping toward the softer gaps where the legs met the body. Better. A Drain Rat slipped from a side channel. Straight toward Eli. The Mage reacted late. The Rat struck his Energy Shield. A blue shimmer flashed around him. Eli retreated several steps.

"Give me a second." He stopped. Jack's attention moved immediately.

"Move."

"My Shield's about to recharge." A wet impact sounded from above. The Sludge Hopper Jack had heard but not yet seen launched itself from a pipe. Straight at Eli. His Energy Shield had not started recharging. Jack crossed the distance and slammed the flat side of the greataxe head into the Hopper's path before it landed cleanly, knocking it sideways through sheer impact rather than a Skill effect. Hannah finished it. The Beetle died shortly afterward, Maya working the joints while Eli kept it slowed.

Eli stared at his Status.

"That was annoying."

"You waited for the Shield."

"That's what recharge is for." Jack adjusted the greataxe against his shoulder, then reconsidered his phrasing.

"Recharge is what happens after you solve the real problem: creating a few seconds when nothing can hit you." Eli frowned.

"That's the same condition."

"Not the same plan." Jack pointed down the tunnel.

"Distance. Corners. Chill. Somebody between you and the enemy. You create a period where nothing can reach you. Recharge happens because you succeeded." Eli thought about that.

"So I shouldn't retreat and wait."

"Retreat somewhere useful."

"Distance is part of the defense." Jack nodded.

"Exactly." Hannah leaned toward Maya.

"That's mentor voice." Jack heard her. He chose not to respond. Hannah caused the next problem herself. Maya had a Sludge Hopper pinned near the edge of a drainage channel. Flurry was working well, the creature had nowhere useful to retreat, and Maya had settled into a clean attack rhythm. Hannah approached from the right. Heavy Strike. The Hopper flew six feet sideways. Maya's next attack hit empty air.

"Hey!"

"Sorry!" The Hopper recovered. Jack killed it before the interruption became dangerous. Hannah looked appropriately guilty.

"That was my fault."

"Yes," Maya said. They continued. Three minutes later, Hannah did it again. This time the target was a Drain Rat. Heavy Strike. Knockback. Maya stopped mid-step.

"Hannah."

"I said sorry last time." Jack raised a hand.

"Call it." Hannah looked at him.

"Call what?"

"If you're about to move something another person is attacking, say so."

"What am I supposed to say?"

"Something short." The next fight arrived almost immediately. Hannah stepped toward a Rat and began her swing.

"Heavy!" The word had barely left her mouth when the mace connected. The Rat moved. Maya's dagger missed.

"Before!" Hannah grimaced.

"Right." Another group. Maya went left. Hannah saw a Hopper lining up.

"Heavy left!" Maya shifted first. Hannah struck. The Hopper flew exactly where Maya expected it to go. Flurry met it on arrival. The monster collapsed. Hannah blinked.

"Oh." Jack nodded.

"Exactly." Solo, knockback was control. In a party, it was still control. It simply belonged to everyone standing near the target. Another note. The next fight demonstrated something else. A Spore Lobber appeared on an upper walkway. SPORE LOBBER Level: 6 Rank: F Damage: Poison Specialization: Area Denial It raised a swollen forelimb and launched two green-gray sacs into the lower corridor.

"Move." The first spore sac burst. Maya cleared it. Jack avoided most of it. Hannah caught the edge. A Poison effect appeared. She swore. Then looked at the status indicator.

"Wait." Jack killed the Lobber before answering. Hannah stared at the Orchard Charm hanging from her neck.

"The ugly necklace works."

"Charm."

"The ugly charm works."

"Yes." Her Poison Resistance was only seven percent. Seven percent was still more than zero. Hannah smiled.

"I knew I liked it."

"You complained when I gave it to you."

"People grow." Jack shook his head. The second sac, which had landed intact farther along the walkway, burst near him. This one clipped his leg. Poison. His Life Regeneration immediately started fighting the loss. Seven point seven per second helped. His sixty-one percent Fire Resistance did not. Neither did Cold. Neither did Lightning. Of course. Elemental Resistance was excellent. It was not universal Resistance. Beginners were going to confuse those two ideas constantly. Another note. The party began to improve.

That was the interesting part. Maya stopped treating Evasion like permission to occupy the center of every fight. When attack pressure rose, she broke away earlier, forcing enemies to reposition instead of continuing a chain of increasingly favorable attack rolls. Eli stopped waiting for Energy Shield recharge and started creating the window it needed. He Chilled pursuers, retreated behind Hannah, used a corner, or let Jack occupy the corridor. Then his Shield recharged.

Hannah called Heavy Strike before using it whenever somebody else had committed to the same target. They were not suddenly experts. They were simply making fewer mistakes. Jack found himself doing less. Good. That was the point. During one fight, a Rustback Beetle held Jack near the center while Maya moved after a Spore Lobber and Eli shifted to avoid a poison cloud. A Drain Rat slipped between them. Straight toward Eli. Jack could have turned. Hannah was closer. She changed direction before he said anything.

One step. Weapon across the Rat's path. The creature redirected toward her. Eli moved. Problem solved. Jack watched Hannah finish it. Jobless remained inefficient. She did not have Warrior's physical specialization, Rogue's movement advantage, or Mage's ranged tools. At the same Level, a specialized Job doing its intended job would generally do that job better. But Hannah had no catastrophic physical weakness.

Twenty Strength, twenty Dexterity, twenty Intelligence: enough to fight, enough to reposition, and no part of her basic statline collapsing completely. A generalist was rarely the best answer. Sometimes it was the answer standing closest to the problem. The bigger issue remained getting a Jobless beginner far enough to have options in the first place. Jack remembered a cardboard sign. Yes. Definitely still a problem. Eli leveled during the next major fight.

The encounter started with a Beetle, two Rats, and a Spore Lobber. Eli used Frost Bolt to slow the Beetle, then helped Hannah control one Rat while Maya moved around the back for the Lobber. Jack finished the final enemy. A System notification appeared in front of Eli. He stopped.

"I leveled." Then he grinned. It was the first time Jack had seen him do that.

"Six." Maya turned.

"You didn't kill that."

"You don't need the last hit," Jack said. Three faces turned toward him. Hannah's expression was the least surprised. Maya asked, "Then what gives Experience?"

"Participation."

"Define participation."

"No." She stared. Jack sighed.

"I can't." That answer confused her more. He continued.

"Last hit isn't required. Meaningful participation matters. Damage can count. Control can count. Support can count. Distance and whether the System considers you part of the encounter matter." Eli looked at his staff.

"I only Chilled the Beetle at the start."

"You did more than that."

"I didn't touch the last monster."

"Didn't need to." Maya's expression had become dangerously analytical.

"So Frost Bolt on a Level Six Beetle gave him—""No. Do not turn one fight into a formula."

"I wasn't."

"You were about to." She smiled.

"Maybe." Jack pointed at Eli.

"Experience requirements vary between people. Contribution weighting isn't fully understood. Different monsters matter differently. There are too many unknowns." Maya nodded slowly.

"So one Frost Bolt isn't worth exactly two point seven percent of a Rat." Jack looked at her.

"Correct." Hannah said, "Someone is posting that exact formula online right now." Jack sighed.

"Probably." Eli started to open his Passive Tree. Jack stopped him.

"Not here." Eli blinked.

"Why?"

"Because this is a hallway in an active Dungeon. Decide your build somewhere that doesn't contain monsters." Eli closed it.

"Right." Hannah looked at Maya.

"Mentor." Jack ignored her. They reached the Boss area after another twenty minutes. The tunnel opened into an enormous circular cistern with a shallow pool occupying most of the floor. Concrete-like pillars supported a high ceiling, while rusted catwalks crossed the chamber at different heights. Large pale sacs clung to the walls. Eggs. Maya stopped before entering.

"Wait. If the Boss drops something really good, who gets it?" Silence. Hannah looked at Eli. Eli looked at Jack. Jack closed his eyes for half a second.

"You didn't decide that before entering." Nobody answered.

"Of course you didn't." Maya looked embarrassed.

"We should have."

"Yes."

"So?" Jack considered the simplest rule that would work for a newly formed party in a seventeen-day-old economy.

"Mana Stones split evenly when the numbers work. If a piece of equipment is an obvious upgrade for only one person, that person gets priority. If multiple people want something valuable, nobody grabs it and decides later." Maya glanced at Eli.

"What about stuff nobody wants?"

"Sell it and split the value." Hannah asked, "Unique?"

"Stop. If a Unique or something we don't understand drops, nobody decides anything until it's identified and we know what we're looking at." Hannah blinked, then nodded. Maya nodded.

"That makes sense."

"It would have made more sense outside."

"Yes." Hannah grinned.

"He's writing this down later."

"Absolutely." Jack looked toward the cistern. One party. Half a Dungeon. Already enough material for several pages. He was beginning to understand why fifteen years of beginner guides had become so long. The Boss waited near the center of the reservoir. It was amphibian only in the broadest possible sense. A massive pale body crouched low over six muscular limbs, its skin slick and almost translucent under the Dungeon light.

Dark sacs pulsed along its sides, and clusters of smaller eggs clung beneath the catwalk supports around it. Jack focused. CISTERN BROODMOTHER Level: 8 Rank: F Damage: Physical / Poison Mobility: Moderate Traits: Summoning Area Control High Life Jack studied the room. Solo, this would not be difficult. That was irrelevant.

"Boss stays on me." Hannah looked at him.

"Tank?"

"Position."

"That sounds like tank with extra words."

"Boss faces me. That's what matters." He pointed.

"Maya, adds first. Boss when the room is clear."

"Got it."

"Hannah, anything Maya doesn't catch. Especially anything moving toward Eli."

"Okay."

"Eli, Frost Bolt where it matters. Boss if nothing else needs slowing." Eli studied the egg clusters rather than simply nodding.

"If several hatch at once, fastest add first or closest?"

"Fastest unless somebody calls for help."

"Got it."

"If your Shield drops?"

"I move behind whoever has space."

"Good." Jack looked at all three.

"Poison on the floor means move. Maya, if you're getting surrounded, call it before you get hit. Hannah, call Heavy Strike direction before contact." Hannah lifted her mace.

"Heavy left."

"Exactly." Maya asked, "Anything else?"

"Nobody tries to be impressive."

"That's disappointing."

"Survive anyway." Then Jack entered. The Broodmother moved faster than something that size should have. Its forelimb crashed down. Jack stepped aside, let the impact strike concrete, then drove the greataxe into the softer tissue behind the joint as the limb passed. The Boss shifted. He moved with it. Not maximizing damage. Managing position. The Broodmother's head stayed pointed away from Eli. Maya moved onto the flank. Flurry. Hannah watched the egg clusters.

Frost Bolt struck the Boss's shoulder and spread pale cold across its skin. Good. Jack could have accelerated the fight. He did not. Solo would have been faster. Good. One of the wall sacs split. Three small creatures dropped into the water. Maya moved. First. Second. The third reached Hannah.

"Heavy right!" Heavy Strike launched it away from Eli. Maya adjusted without losing her target. Better. The Boss spat a thick stream of dark fluid across the cistern.

"Move." Everyone moved. Poison spread where they had been standing. Eli's Frost Bolt launched from a new angle. The party worked. Not perfectly. Well enough. Then the second wave hatched. Maya took one. Two. Three. A fourth came from behind a pillar. Her first instinct was visible. Stay. Finish. Then she changed it.

"Too many!" Hannah peeled one away. Jack turned Cleave just enough to catch another without giving the Boss his back. Pressure dropped. Maya moved. Her Evasion started working for her again instead of being asked to rescue a bad position.

"Good call," Jack said.

"I learn."

"Good." The Broodmother slammed forward. Jack stepped off-line rather than trying to absorb the whole charge. Something splashed behind him. Eli. Poison had clipped the Mage. His Energy Shield flashed and dropped hard.

"Shield low!" He moved. Did not stop. Good. A newly hatched creature followed. Frost Bolt. Chill. Eli retreated behind Hannah. She intercepted. The Poison faded while he kept moving behind her. Several more seconds passed without damage. Blue light rebuilt around him.

"Back."

"Good." Jack felt absurdly satisfied. He had not killed anything during that exchange. It might have been the most productive part of the Dungeon. The Broodmother's next poison spray caught Jack along one side. His Life dropped. Poison continued afterward. Seven point seven Life per second pushed back. Not enough to make the effect irrelevant. Enough to reduce the attrition. Jack adjusted. The Dungeon did not care that his Fire, Cold, and Lightning Resistance were all sixty-one percent. Poison was Poison.

Another problem future beginners would eventually learn to separate automatically. Day Seventeen beginners were still going to read the word Resistance and assume categories were broader than they actually were. He would need to make that clearer. Later. The Boss was not finished. Its Life had fallen far enough that several remaining egg clusters ruptured at once. The room changed. Adds everywhere. Maya took a hit. Eli's Mana was running low.

He used his Mana Flask, checked his Mana, and kept his next cast ready instead of spending it immediately. Hannah moved toward the Boss with her mace already raised. Jack saw it.

"Adds." One word. Hannah stopped.

"Right." She turned. No argument. No hesitation. One of the smaller creatures had reached Maya's blind side. Hannah intercepted it. Maya recovered. Eli started forming another Frost Bolt at the Boss. Jack opened his mouth to redirect him. Eli had already changed targets. The Bolt flew into the fastest add moving toward Maya. Chill spread. Movement slowed. Good. Jack kept the Broodmother occupied alone. For several seconds, nobody attacked the Boss except him. That was fine. Better than fine. It was correct. Tank.

Damage. Support. Those words were useful until people started treating them like laws. What mattered was simpler. Who needed to hold the Boss? Who needed to remove the adds? Who needed to slow something? Who needed to create room for somebody else? Roles were not Jobs. Roles were whatever needed doing in the next five seconds. The adds died. Maya came back around the flank. Eli raised his staff, ready with another Frost Bolt. Hannah raised her mace.

"Heavy left!" Jack moved one step. Heavy Strike landed. The Broodmother shifted exactly where Maya expected. Flurry hit from the opposite side. Frost Bolt struck. Jack brought Cleave through the opening. The Boss collapsed into the shallow water. Silence followed. Then four people exhaled at approximately the same time. Nobody had reached zero Life. Nobody had used a Portal Scroll. Nobody had panicked. Jack looked at the dead Boss. Solo would have been faster. The party had been more useful.

The loot appeared near the center platform. Four Mana Stones. Maya stared at them.

"That's suspiciously convenient."

"Do not build expectations around one loot pile."

"You really hate conclusions."

"I hate bad ones." There was more. A pair of Rare gloves built around Evasion. A Magic staff. A Life Flask. Several Common pieces nobody immediately cared about. No Skill Gem. No necklace. Jack refused to be disappointed. This had not been a loot run. Mostly. He identified everything. The gloves were an obvious Maya upgrade. The staff was better than Eli's current weapon, though not dramatically. Hannah had the smallest Flask reserve. Easy.

"Gloves to Maya. Staff to Eli. Flask to Hannah. One Mana Stone each." Maya looked at Jack.

"You don't want anything?"

"Nothing here is an upgrade." Hannah looked at Goldrim. Then at Jack. Jack noticed.

"Don't."

"I didn't say anything."

"You were going to."

"Probably." Maya looked between them.

"What?"

"Nothing," Hannah said. Jack approved of that answer. The remaining Common equipment went into a pile to sell later. Nobody argued. Apparently loot rules were useful. Shocking. Outside Cedar Run, the afternoon market was busier than before. The four of them stopped near the edge of the parking lot. Maya stretched.

"Okay. That was way smoother than my last party." Jack looked at her.

"What happened last time?"

"Nobody agreed who was going first."

"Before entering?"

"Inside." Jack closed his eyes.

"Of course." Another note. Maya laughed.

"You do this a lot?"

"Enough."

"You're weirdly good at explaining beginner mistakes." Hannah answered immediately.

"That's his hobby."

"It isn't."

"You literally corrected my shopping list."

"Your shopping list was wrong."

"Mentor behavior." Jack looked at her.

"You keep using that word like it's an insult."

"It isn't." That made him pause. Only briefly. Eli adjusted the new staff.

"I'll fix the Shield habit."

"You already started." Eli looked pleased.

"And the target priority thing." Jack nodded.

"You did that without waiting for me."

"I figured if you were about to yell, I should probably save you the effort." Maya looked at Jack.

"He's learning your personality too."

"That may be less useful." Numbers were exchanged. Maya raised her phone.

"Next time?"

"Maybe." Then Maya and Eli headed toward the market. Hannah remained. Jack looked at her.

"So."

"So." She shifted her mace onto one shoulder.

"Did I pass?"

"What?"

"The test."

"There wasn't a test."

"You watched everything I did."

"I watch everything everyone does."

"That does not make it less like a test." Jack considered the argument. Annoyingly reasonable.

"You did well." Hannah stopped.

"Oh."

"Don't make that weird."

"You actually complimented me."

"I've complimented you before."

"Name one." Jack opened his mouth. Stopped. Hannah smiled. He tried again.

"Your Resistance choices are acceptable."

"That's not a compliment."

"It is from me."

"There he is." She laughed. Then glanced toward the parking lot where Maya had disappeared.

"I'm still slower than her."

"At what?"

"Killing things."

"She's a Rogue using a damage-oriented Skill. You're Jobless using Heavy Strike."

"Exactly."

"So stop measuring yourself using her Job." Hannah frowned. Jack continued.

"Eli was about to get hit. Who stopped it?"

"Me."

"Maya got pressured by adds. Who took one?"

"Me."

"When the fight changed, who could move from one job to another without becoming useless?" Hannah looked at him.

"Me."

"That's useful." She was quiet for a moment. Jack added, "Don't confuse useful with optimal. Your build still needs work." Hannah sighed.

"There he is." Jack smiled slightly.

"One more thing before you go," Jack said.

"Federal representatives came to my house yesterday. They worked out who runs GateGuide." Hannah stared at him. Then her eyes widened with an expression he recognized immediately.

"I knew it."

"You suspected."

"You told me he sounded more annoying."

"He does." She almost laughed. Then the other part of what he had said caught up with her, and she glanced toward the market before lowering her voice.

"Did you tell them about my Skill?"

"No. Your name and your Unique weren't part of the conversation." Her shoulders eased.

"You should have opened with that. Are they making you stop posting?"

"No. I have that in writing. We're trying a limited information exchange. They send material cleared for external review; I tell them what Appraisal can establish. Formal consulting terms are still being worked out." Hannah studied him.

"So the government gets homework too."

"Apparently."

"I feel better about mine."

"You still have to do it." That earned him a familiar look. She glanced around once more.

"Who else knows you're GateGuide?"

"People involved in the federal contact. Now you. The account is still anonymous to the public. I'd like to keep it that way."

"I can do that." She hesitated.

"And the advice about talking to them? About my Unique?"

"Still your decision. My contact with them doesn't make it an appointment you have to attend. You don't need to decide today." For once, Hannah let that answer stand.

"Okay. Thanks." Jack nodded. He could share what had changed without handing over something that belonged to her. Potential was not the same thing as access. Hannah possessed an SSS Skill capable of eventually becoming something absurd. Today, there were no Aura Skill Gems in her hands. So she hit monsters with a mace. That was fine. Progression required things to progress. He was not going to pretend the future had already arrived just because he knew what it looked like.

Jack did not enter Layer Four that evening. He had enough to process. The notebook came out first. PARTY DATA — CEDAR RUN EVASION Knowing the percentage is not the same as managing pressure. ENERGY SHIELD Recharge is the result. Creating space is the plan. FORCED MOVEMENT Call knockback direction before impact. JOBLESS Generalist flexibility matters more in parties than expected. Do not overhype before Jewel access. POISON Elemental Resistance does not cover Poison. EXPERIENCE Last hit not required.

Meaningful participation counts. Exact weighting unknown. DO NOT INVENT FORMULA. Jack underlined the last line twice. LOOT Set rules before entry. PARTY Jobs are not roles. Assign functions before entering. Combat-relevant information matters more than private Unique details. He stopped. Then added: SAMPLE SIZE: ONE PARTY. Do not generalize individual behavior. Maya was one Rogue. Eli was one Mage. Hannah was one extremely unusual Jobless Delver carrying a secret SSS Skill she could not actually use yet.

None of them represented an entire Job. Jack waited. Then added: Still useful. He leaned back. Fifteen years later, beginner guides would look clean. Organized. Polished. Evasion. Energy Shield. Party positioning. Loot etiquette. Damage categories. Experience sharing. Everything reduced into compact rules that felt obvious because millions of people had already made the mistakes required to discover them. Jack remembered the answers. He did not remember every question that had once been necessary.

That was the problem. Future knowledge gave him answers. Beginners reminded him which questions people still needed to ask. His laptop chimed. Another government upload. Rachel Keene's pilot folder. Jack opened the index without opening the files. F. F. E. F. More private Gates. He closed it again. Tomorrow. Government reports would tell him what institutions did not understand. Public parties would tell him what ordinary people did not understand. Both were information.

Jack looked back at the older note he had written several days ago. Solo runs produced loot. Parties produced data. Then he looked at the notes from a single F-rank run. He had badly underestimated the second one.