Chương 15: Chapter 12 — Anonymous to the Internet

One moment — Royal Road is checking your connection · ParallelGamer · 84 chương · ~59 phút đọc · Tạo 27/09/2026

Day Sixteen. Jack was halfway through breakfast when somebody rang the doorbell. He looked up from his laptop. The browser still showed the same argument it had shown ten minutes ago. PRIVATE GATE IN FAMILY BARN — CAN THE STATE TAKE OUR LAND? The original poster claimed a blue Gate had appeared behind two tractors sometime during Day One and that his family had spent nearly two weeks arguing about whether telling anyone was a good idea. Technically, the federal government had already answered part of that question.

On Day Seven, after corporate pressure, landowner outrage, and the practical impossibility of guarding every Gate in America had become impossible to ignore, Washington had announced that there would be no universal federal prohibition on entering Gates located on private property. Secured military sites were exceptions, state and local rules still applied, and nobody was promising rescue to people who walked into a Dungeon and discovered they had made a terrible decision.

That had settled whether the federal government intended to ban private access everywhere. It had not settled what happened after somebody actually reported a Gate in their barn. The replies beneath the thread demonstrated the distinction beautifully. One group insisted the family should call the authorities immediately. Another claimed the county would condemn the farm. Several people argued that property rights meant the family should be able to charge admission.

A lawyer with an alarming number of disclaimers explained that nobody currently knew whether Dungeon resources resembled mineral rights, found property, hazardous material, or something entirely new. Someone else suggested selling tickets. Jack had stopped reading that branch. The law had made progress. The law was still approximately fifteen years away from becoming something a normal person could navigate without three attorneys and a headache. The doorbell rang again. Jack checked the security camera.

Two black SUVs sat at the curb. Three people stood on his front porch wearing business clothes rather than tactical gear, and the woman in front already had identification ready in one hand. Another carried a slim document case. Jack stared at the image for a moment.

"There it is." Sixteen days. Honestly, longer than he had expected. He closed the browser and stood. GateGuide had been anonymous to the internet. That was not the same thing as being anonymous to the federal government. Jack had never routed every connection through six countries, bought computers with cash, created an elaborate false identity, or otherwise behaved like someone trying to disappear from the state.

He used a normal internet connection, posted regularly from the same general area, visited North Ridge in person, bought Dungeon equipment under his own name, and generally acted like someone who wanted strangers online to leave him alone rather than someone hiding from a national investigation. If the federal government had seriously decided to find GateGuide, eventually it was going to find Jack Mercer. Apparently eventually was today. He opened the door. The woman at the front gave him a professional smile.

"Mr. Mercer?"

"Yes." She raised her identification.

"Rachel Keene. Federal interagency Gate response coordination. This is Special Agent Harris, and Dr. Patel is working with the technical assessment group." Jack looked over the credentials carefully. Names. Photographs. Agencies. Nothing visibly wrong.

"All right." Keene studied his face for a moment.

"We'd like to speak with you about an online account called GateGuide." Jack nodded.

"Sure." There was a small pause. He added, "You already know it's mine." The pause became slightly longer. Keene smiled despite herself.

"Yes."

"Good. Saves time." Ten minutes later, three federal employees were sitting around Jack's dining table. Nobody had objected when he offered coffee. Patel had accepted. Harris had not. Keene had hesitated for approximately two seconds before apparently deciding that whatever interim federal procedure covered contact with anonymous Dungeon information sources did not forbid caffeine.

Fifteen years later, conversations involving high-value Appraisal Skills, private Dungeons, and federal Dungeon policy would happen inside buildings designed specifically for those purposes. Today, Rachel Keene was putting a government document case beside a coaster Jack's mother had bought years ago. Progress had to start somewhere. Keene opened a notebook.

"First, basic confirmation. You operate the GateGuide account?"

"Yes."

"Alone?"

"Yes."

"No organization, research group, company, or other individual supplies the information posted under that account?"

"No."

"And the identifications you've provided publicly—Mana Stones, monsters, equipment, consumables—are primarily your own work?"

"Yes." Keene glanced at her notes.

"Through a Unique Skill?" Jack had expected that question.

"My Unique Skill is Appraisal." Patel's coffee stopped halfway to her mouth.

"Rank?" Jack did not answer instantly. He had deliberately kept that part off the internet. Strangers did not need to know that GateGuide's Appraisal was A-rank, and advertising an unusually valuable information Skill to millions of people had offered him no benefit at all. This was different. The three people sitting at his table already knew his name, address, account, and enough about his activity to find him at breakfast.

More importantly, they were asking to build a working relationship around the Skill itself. Understating its capability now would simply create a different problem later.

"A." The room became noticeably quieter. Not dramatically. Nobody reached for a phone or started shouting. Patel lowered her mug, Keene's pen paused over the page, and Harris looked at Jack with slightly more interest than before. Patel spoke first.

"That explains quite a lot."

"Most of the easy parts." Keene caught the qualifier.

"Easy parts?"

"Appraisal lets me understand things other people can't identify yet. Direct observation works best. Clear photographs and video can work too, depending on quality and what I'm looking at. That's why people can send GateGuide pictures of drops."

"And monsters?"

"Same principle."

"Skill Gems?"

"If the image gives me enough information." Patel leaned forward.

"How much detail?"

"Variable. Direct sight is strongest. With images, lighting, resolution, motion blur, compression, obstruction—all of that can affect the result."

"So asking people for clear photographs wasn't just you being particular."

"No. It was data quality." Patel wrote something down. Keene kept watching him.

"Does Appraisal explain everything you've published?" Jack considered lying. Not seriously. Just long enough to decide it would create more problems than it solved.

"No." Harris spoke for the first time since sitting down.

"What doesn't it explain?"

"Appraisal tells me what something is." Jack glanced toward his laptop on the counter.

"Experience tells me why I should care." Keene's expression remained neutral.

"The Gates appeared sixteen days ago."

"I noticed."

"And you've accumulated enough experience in sixteen days to recognize which unidentified Dungeon objects matter for public safety before some laboratories have finished deciding how to store them." Jack shrugged slightly.

"I've had an unusual sixteen days." Harris did not look satisfied. That was fair. Keene, however, did not push harder. Not yet. They had come because GateGuide was useful, not because somebody had assembled a conspiracy board and decided Jack Mercer was personally responsible for the existence of magic. Keene turned a page.

"Before today, GateGuide was an anonymous account publishing highly specific Dungeon information without a verified source. Multiple agencies have been monitoring your posts since Day One." Jack nodded.

"I assumed so."

"Some of those posts are already being used as preliminary reference material." Jack frowned.

"That sounds unsafe." Patel smiled.

"They're independently verified."

"Better."

"So far," Keene said, "your accuracy has been extremely high."

"So far?"

"We're the government. We qualify sentences." Jack considered that.

"Fair."

"Your Mana Stone identification accelerated laboratory work. Your warnings about ordinary ammunition and equipment requirements stopped several agencies from repeating mistakes civilians had already made. Portal Scroll information is being incorporated into emergency procedures. Modified versions of your beginner defensive guidance are circulating among local response teams." Jack blinked.

"Modified?"

"Government writing has fewer jokes."

"That sounds worse." Patel laughed into her coffee. Keene ignored both of them.

"The point is that we're not here because GateGuide has become a problem. We're here because GateGuide has become useful enough that we would prefer to know who we're relying on."

"Reasonable." Jack remembered the question he had intended to ask whenever this meeting finally happened.

"Before we go any further, I want one thing clarified." Keene folded her hands.

"All right."

"I intend to keep operating GateGuide." Harris glanced at Keene. Patel looked between them. Jack continued.

"Is the federal government asking me to stop?"

"No," Keene said. Jack waited. She noticed.

"I'd like that stated a little more clearly." For the first time, Harris looked amused. Keene took a breath.

"Mr. Mercer, as of today, the federal government is not directing you to stop operating the GateGuide account. We are not requesting that you surrender control of the account, and we are not asking you to stop publishing Dungeon information you obtain independently."

"Good."

"If you later receive classified information, sealed investigative material, protected personal information, or anything else subject to legal restrictions, that is a separate matter."

"Obviously."

"And if you identify something that presents an immediate public-safety threat, we would strongly prefer that you contact us before it becomes the number one trending topic in the country." Jack considered that.

"Before or at the same time." Keene stared at him.

"We'll work on that."

"Put the first part in writing." Harris actually laughed. Keene gave Jack a long look.

"You planned that question."

"I planned to ask it whenever you showed up."

"We can provide a written summary of today's federal position."

"Federal?"

"Yes." Keene's tone sharpened slightly.

"I can tell you what the federal government is doing today. I cannot bind your state, your county, Congress, a future agency, or a court that hasn't heard a case yet." Jack nodded.

"Fair." That was better, actually. Specific promises were useful. Impossible promises were not. Jack had not asked for permission. That distinction mattered. The federal government was not granting GateGuide a license to exist. Jack wanted a record that, after identifying him and speaking with him directly, the government was not currently ordering him to stop. Unlawfully taken from Royal Road, this story should be reported if seen on Amazon.

Future arguments became much easier when yesterday's assumptions existed in writing. Keene closed that page.

"Now we get to what we want."

"There it is."

"We would like to establish a working relationship." Jack did not answer immediately. Patel opened a folder. Inside were printed photographs. Dungeon equipment. Monster screenshots. A strange crystalline object sitting inside a plastic evidence container. Several images had handwritten case numbers across the bottom.

"We are receiving thousands of reports," she said.

"Unknown equipment. Unknown consumables. Unidentified monsters. Strange environmental effects. Videos from local law enforcement, state agencies, federal teams, military personnel, private landowners, companies, hospitals, universities—everybody has something they want explained."

"And not enough Appraisers."

"We have Appraisers," Patel said.

"Their capabilities vary enormously. Rank varies. Scope varies. Some require direct contact. Some specialize in materials. One person we've identified is excellent with equipment and almost useless with monsters."

"Not surprising." Her eyes narrowed slightly. Jack had almost said normal. He was getting better at that. Keene continued.

"You have a high-rank Appraisal Skill, remote-image capability, and a demonstrated understanding of Dungeon terminology. We would like permission to send selected material to you for assessment."

"I don't want a federal job."

"We're not offering one."

"Good."

"At least not today." Jack looked at her. Keene's expression did not change. He decided to assume that had been a joke. Mostly.

"What are you offering?"

"Initially, a limited consulting arrangement. Specific requests, specific compensation, no requirement that you stop independent activity. If it proves useful, we can discuss something more formal." Money was not the interesting part. Information was.

"If you want my information, I want yours." Harris leaned back slightly. Keene said, "Define yours."

"Dungeon data."

"What kind?"

"Unknown monster footage. Unidentified drops. Private Gate reports. Unusual System behavior. First-clear observations. Anything you're already looking at and saying, 'We don't know what this is.'" Harris shook his head.

"We're not giving a civilian access to federal investigative files."

"I didn't ask for names, addresses, witness statements, or criminal records." Jack pointed at Patel's folder.

"Strip the identifying information. Send me the part you don't understand." Harris did not immediately object again. Instead, he tapped one finger against the table.

"Even sanitized files can reveal things through context. Location, architecture, uniforms, weather, timestamps. If we send you material, somebody has to review what the image itself gives away, not just remove a name from the metadata." Jack paused. That was true.

"Fair." Patel nodded.

"We can build a small pilot set. Material cleared specifically for external technical review."

"That's enough to start." Keene wrote that down. Not full access. Not a federal database password. A handful of approved cases. That was how real cooperation usually began. Keene asked, "Why private Gate reports specifically?" Jack glanced toward the backyard.

"Because they're going to matter." Her eyes sharpened. That answer had landed. Jack continued before she could ask the obvious follow-up.

"And because future know—" He stopped. Nobody moved. Jack corrected smoothly.

"Future planning requires knowing whether something is an isolated case or a pattern." Harris watched him for a second longer than was comfortable. Keene said, "Reasonable." Close. Too close. Jack made a mental note to stop beginning sentences with the word future around federal investigators. The conversation shifted. Keene wanted to know how GateGuide decided what to publish. That question was harder than it sounded. Jack could not exactly answer: Fifteen years of hindsight.

So he gave her the operational version.

"If something is likely to get people killed because they don't know it, I publish."

"Examples?"

"Firearms. Portal Scrolls. Equipment requirements. Basic defense."

"And things you don't publish?"

"Information that doesn't help people survive right now. Things that could distort a market before supply exists. Progression mechanics people aren't ready to use. Anything I'm not confident is correct." Harris said, "You are intentionally withholding Dungeon information."

"Yes." No hesitation. That appeared to surprise him more than denial would have. Keene asked, "Significant information?"

"Some."

"Potentially valuable?"

"Absolutely."

"Potentially dangerous?" Jack thought about Skill Gem leveling, future Rank penalties, and mechanics that would eventually turn cheap beginner materials into strategic commodities.

"Some information becomes dangerous depending on how it's released." Patel nodded slowly.

"Demand shock."

"Among other things." Keene tapped her pen once.

"And you decide when humanity is ready?"

"No."

"That sounded like what you were describing." Jack shook his head.

"I decide what I personally publish under my own account. If somebody else discovers the same thing tomorrow and posts it, that's their decision. I'm not controlling information. I'm choosing not to dump every advanced mechanic I know into a world that learned what Mana was two weeks ago." There it was again. Know. Harris noticed. Of course he did. Jack continued anyway.

"If something is going to get people killed because they don't know it, I don't sit on it." That mattered more. Keene studied him, then nodded.

"All right. Then let me ask the obvious question. Is there anything you currently know about that presents an immediate safety problem and has not been adequately addressed?" Jack's eyes moved toward the back of the house. He had known this moment was coming before they rang the bell.

"Yes." All three of them went still. Keene's pen stopped.

"What?"

"Private Dungeons." Harris frowned.

"Private Dungeons?"

"Gate appearances on private property." Keene's expression changed by approximately half a degree. Enough. Jack saw it.

"You already have reports." She did not answer immediately.

"How many?"

"We're not discussing numbers." Jack leaned back.

"Enough that you didn't ask what I meant." Patel looked at Keene. Keene sighed.

"Yes. We have reports."

"Confirmed?"

"Some."

"Residential?"

"Some."

"Farms?"

"Yes."

"Commercial property?"

"Yes."

"Warehouses?" Harris raised a hand.

"Mr. Mercer." Jack stopped.

"Fine." Keene asked, "Why is that your immediate concern? The federal government already removed the blanket prohibition on private-property Gate entry."

"I know." That answer stopped Harris from delivering the argument he had clearly been preparing. Jack continued.

"I'm not talking about whether Washington bans every property owner from entering. I'm talking about what happens after somebody tells you they have one." Keene leaned back slightly. Jack pointed toward the laptop.

"There's a family online right now asking whether reporting a Gate in their barn will cost them control of their farm."

"That isn't federal policy," Harris said.

"Good."

"Automatic seizure isn't federal policy either."

"Also good." Harris's expression shifted. Jack nodded toward him.

"That's useful information. Does every sheriff's department know what to do tomorrow morning if somebody calls about a Gate in a basement?"

"No," Harris admitted.

"Does every county?"

"No."

"Every state?"

"No."

"Then that's the problem I'm talking about." This time Harris did not argue. Keene looked between them. Jack stood.

"Come outside." Harris's hand moved instinctively toward his jacket. Jack looked at him.

"If I was planning something dramatic, I probably wouldn't have made coffee first."

"People have done stranger things."

"Fair." Jack headed toward the back door.

"There's something you should see." The shed looked ordinary from outside. That was still one of Jack's favorite things about it. Sixteen days into the new world, reality had become comfortable enough with absurdity to place one of the most important objects in Jack's life behind a cheap wooden door with a weathered handle. He unlocked it. Keene stood slightly behind him. Harris had moved to one side, while Patel was already holding her phone even though she had not started recording. Jack opened the door.

Blue light spilled across the yard. Nobody spoke for several seconds. Patel was first.

"Oh." Keene stared into the shed. Harris looked from the Gate to Jack, then back again.

"You have a Dungeon in your shed."

"Technically, the shed is around the Dungeon." Harris turned his head.

"That does not improve the sentence." Jack smiled faintly.

"I know." The Gate hummed. Stable. Quiet. Exactly as it had every day since Day One. Keene recovered first.

"How long has this been here?"

"Since the first day." Her head snapped toward him.

"You've known about a private Gate for sixteen days."

"Yes."

"And you didn't report it."

"To whom?" That stopped her. Jack continued.

"On Day One, the official advice was to surrender recovered material and stay away from Gates. Half the country was still arguing about whether Mana Stones were radioactive. There wasn't a functioning private-Gate registration system for me to call." Keene didn't dispute that.

"I wanted to know whether this thing was stable before I invited strangers into my backyard."

"And?"

"It is."

"So far," Harris said. Jack looked at him.

"Yes." The qualifier was correct. Keene stepped closer to the doorway but did not cross the threshold.

"Have you entered?"

"Repeatedly." Patel looked at him.

"Of course you have."

"It's a Layered Dungeon." Her attention sharpened instantly.

"Layered?" Jack activated Appraisal. The familiar interface appeared in his vision. He did not read all of it aloud. Some information still belonged to him. LAYERED DUNGEON Status: Unclaimed Current Accessible Layer: 4 Current Threat Rank: F Patel began writing.

"Total depth?"

"Unknown."

"Total number of layers?"

"Unknown."

"Your Appraisal can't determine it?"

"Not everything." That answer was completely true. He did not mention: Known Depth:??? Total Layers:??? And he definitely did not mention: Origin: UNKNOWN The government was here to discuss private Gate handling. Jack had no intention of turning the conversation into a federal investigation of why his specific Dungeon contained a System field he had never seen before in fifteen years. One problem at a time. Keene asked, "Any monster emergence?"

"No."

"Environmental effects outside the Gate?"

"No."

"Changes to the property?"

"Nothing beyond the Gate itself."

"Loot?"

"Ordinary Dungeon loot."

"Mana Stones?"

"Yes."

"Skill Gems?"

"Yes."

"Bosses?"

"Yes."

"How much have you actually cleared?"

"The first three layers. I'm farming Layer Four now. Its Guardian is still alive." That answer changed the tone slightly. Not because the government suddenly became alarmed. Because it was useful. Keene asked, "Highest confirmed monster Level?"

"Seven."

"Your Level?"

"Seven." Harris frowned.

"You're fighting Level Seven monsters alone?"

"Yes."

"Successfully."

"Usually."

"Usually?"

"Nothing involving combat should be described as guaranteed." Harris considered that.

"Good answer." Jack looked at him.

"Thank you." Patel asked, "Does Layer Four contain anything above F-rank?"

"Not that I've confirmed."

"Any indication the Dungeon itself will change Rank?"

"It's layered. Rank increases deeper down."

"How much deeper?"

"Unknown." Keene nodded.

"That's enough for initial hazard planning." Then she asked the question Jack had been expecting.

"Can we enter?"

"No." All three looked at him. Jack pointed at Harris's shoes, then Patel's, then Keene's suit.

"None of you brought Dungeon equipment."

"We aren't planning to fight anything," Keene said.

"Neither was half the internet the first time something went wrong."

"We would stay at the entrance."

"No." Harris folded his arms.

"You're refusing federal access?"

"I'm refusing three unprepared people permission to walk into an active Dungeon through my property without proper Gear, Flasks, or a Portal Scroll." Patel considered that.

"He's right." Harris looked at her.

"He is." Jack nodded.

"Thank you." Keene pinched the bridge of her nose briefly.

"All right. Not today."

"Bring properly equipped personnel and we can discuss an entrance inspection."

"Discuss?"

"It's still my backyard." That brought them directly to the real issue. Keene looked at the Gate again.

"About that." Jack nodded.

"Exactly." They stayed outside. That felt appropriate. The federal government did not yet have a standard conference room for discussing privately owned Dungeons, so Jack's backyard had to serve. Keene explained what she could. Jack had been correct that his Gate was not unique. Private-property Gates had already been confirmed in houses, farms, commercial lots, warehouses, privately owned woodland, and industrial property. One report involved a detached garage. Another involved a company storage building.

The federal position from Day Seven had prevented one obvious disaster: there was no universal nationwide rule automatically forbidding property owners from entering every private Gate. That did not mean the practical response was standardized. Some local authorities had closed affected buildings while they tried to determine whether the Gate represented a hazard. Some state agencies had imposed temporary access restrictions. Some owners had continued entering.

Several companies had hired security and begun treating their Gates as corporate assets before anybody had fully decided what obligations came with that. At least a few disputes were already headed toward court. More importantly, Harris added, the federal government could not simply order every county, city, state agency, fire marshal, insurer, employer, and property regulator in the country to use one identical procedure tomorrow morning. Jack nodded.

"That is exactly the problem." Harris looked mildly surprised that Jack had agreed.

"You thought I was arguing for federal ownership?"

"I wasn't sure what you were arguing for."

"A reporting system that people actually use." Keene folded her arms.

"What would that require?" Jack laughed once.

"I'm not a lawyer."

"You seem comfortable giving policy advice."

"I'm comfortable telling you how people respond to incentives."

"And?" Jack pointed toward the house.

"If reporting a Dungeon means losing practical control of your home, farm, warehouse, or business for an undefined amount of time, people will stop reporting Dungeons." Keene did not immediately answer. Jack continued.

"Forget permanent seizure. It doesn't have to be that dramatic. Somebody reports a Gate in a barn. The property gets closed for three weeks while five agencies argue over jurisdiction. Their address leaks. People show up to look at the magic portal. Their insurer panics. They lose access to part of the farm." Patel winced.

"Some of that is already happening around public Gates."

"Exactly." Jack spread his hands.

"Now the neighbor sees what happened. Three weeks later, a Gate appears in his basement." Keene said, "Maybe he doesn't call."

"He absolutely doesn't if the first guy tells him not to." Harris spoke.

"And if we make the response too permissive, people will understate hazards because they want to keep access. Businesses could hide injuries, owners could let untrained people enter, and nobody outside the property would know whether monsters can emerge." Jack pointed at him.

"Yes." Harris frowned.

"That's the point." This time Patel laughed. Jack continued.

"Private citizens concealing dangerous Gates is bad. So make voluntary reporting the less dangerous option." Unregistered entry. Children wandering inside. Loot sold with no documented source. Deaths concealed because reporting them might expose the Gate. Unknown monster behavior never reaching anyone outside the property. Criminal use. Companies quietly sending workers into private Dungeons without standards. None of that required evil people.

It only required people deciding that disclosure created more problems than concealment.

"Make reporting safer than hiding," Jack said. Keene repeated it quietly.

"Safer than hiding."

"People don't need to love the rules. They need to believe telling you is less dangerous to their life than keeping quiet." Keene looked at him for several seconds.

"You're not the first person to raise versions of that concern."

"Good." That answer seemed to surprise her. Jack shrugged.

"I'd be worried if I was."

"Our lawyers have raised it. Several state officials have raised it. So have property owners who are currently very unhappy with us."

"Excellent."

"I don't think they'd use that word."

"The fact that they're arguing about the right problem is excellent." Keene shook her head slightly.

"The problem is jurisdiction. Emergency powers. Property law. Workplace law. Resource ownership. Public safety. State authority. Federal authority. Nobody wrote any of this for Dungeons."

"Then don't solve every question at once." Harris asked, "You have a simpler version?"

"Registration first." Jack gestured toward the shed.

"Make it easy to report a private Gate without immediately forcing every ownership question to be answered. Record the location. Inspect for public danger. Determine whether monsters can emerge. Determine the Rank and basic threat level. Give the owner clear temporary rules while the rest gets sorted out."

"And ownership of the resources?" Harris asked.

"Later."

"Commercial access?"

"Later."

"Tax?"

"Later." Patel smiled.

"You really do prioritize."

"People can argue about who owes what percentage after they stop hiding portals in barns." Leaving Emily's future alone had meant not interfering with a path that was already working. This was different. Jack was not trying to reconstruct fifteen years of American Dungeon law from memory, and he had no interest in writing statutes at his kitchen table. He was trying to keep the first practical rules from teaching people that secrecy was safer than cooperation. That was enough.

Keene asked, "What about immediate public danger?"

"If monsters are coming out, if the Gate is unstable, if the property is contaminated, if the owner is letting fifty untrained people charge inside for twenty dollars a ticket—intervene."

"So you're not arguing that private property means unrestricted Dungeon control."

"No." Jack looked toward the Gate.

"I'm arguing that voluntary reporting needs to remain rational." Fifteen years later, the American system would be messy, decentralized, litigated, periodically ridiculous, and generally functional. Jack did not need to reproduce every step that led there. He only needed the early system not to make the stupidest possible first move. Keene asked, "And you're volunteering this Gate as a test case?"

"Yes." Harris looked at him sharply. Jack continued.

"Register mine. Document the entrance. Send a properly equipped inspection team later. I'll report major changes, unusual behavior, and anything that affects public safety." Keene folded her arms.

"In return?"

"Don't seize my backyard." Patel looked away to hide a smile. Jack continued before Keene could answer.

"Keep the location restricted within whatever federal records you control. Don't publish my address. Don't issue a federal emergency order stopping me from using a stable F-rank Dungeon without an actual safety reason. Give me one federal contact instead of making me answer the same questions for six agencies."

"And the information exchange."

"Yes." Keene was quiet for several seconds. Then she shook her head.

"I can give you less than that today." Jack waited.

"I can ensure our team treats the location as restricted federal information pending review. I cannot promise your county, your state, a court, or some other agency will never lawfully obtain or disclose it."

"Fair."

"I can tell you we are not taking seizure action today. I cannot promise nobody will ever seek an order if the hazard assessment changes."

"Fair."

"I can tell you our team is not issuing a federal emergency prohibition on your own access today. State law and any later safety findings remain separate."

"Also fair."

"I can designate a federal point of contact."

"Good."

"And I can authorize Patel's group to assemble a small sanitized pilot package for external Appraisal review. You are not getting general access to government Dungeon files."

"I didn't expect to." Harris looked at him.

"You asked like you did."

"You negotiate from the useful version."

"That sounds exhausting."

"It works." Keene closed her notebook.

"Those are the things I can actually say standing in your backyard." Jack nodded. That was enough. More importantly, it was real. Before leaving, Patel asked Jack to repeat the basic Appraisal information for the Gate. He did. Only the information he had decided to share. LAYERED DUNGEON Status: Unclaimed Current Accessible Layer: 4 Current Threat Rank: F Keene stopped him.

"Unclaimed."

"Yes."

"What does that mean?"

"System terminology."

"Can it be claimed?" Jack looked at the word. He had wondered the same thing every day.

"I don't know."

"Does Appraisal show a procedure?"

"No."

"Have you tried?"

"No." Harris raised an eyebrow.

"You've cleared three layers, spent multiple days farming the fourth, fought several Bosses, and you haven't tried to claim the mysterious Dungeon behind your house."

"I don't experiment with unknown ownership mechanics on irreplaceable property." Patel nodded immediately.

"Reasonable." Harris looked betrayed. Jack appreciated her support. Keene asked one final question.

"If it changes?"

"I tell you."

"If the Rank changes?"

"I tell you."

"If monsters begin emerging?"

"You'll know before I finish dialing."

"If your Appraisal reveals something new about its structure?" Jack paused. That category was too broad.

"Something relevant to public safety?" Keene caught the distinction.

"Something relevant to public safety."

"Yes." Good. Specific promises were better than vague ones. They returned to the house. Keene packed her notes. Harris checked his phone. Patel finished the coffee. At the front door, Keene handed Jack a card. Her name. A federal office number. A government email address. Jack turned it over. Nothing on the back.

"That's it?" She frowned.

"Were you expecting something else?"

"I don't know. Secure satellite phone. Red handset. Black briefcase."

"It's Day Sixteen." Jack looked at the card again.

"Fair."

"For ordinary contact, use the number or email. If we need to move restricted files, we'll give you an approved method."

"So email."

"Government email."

"Very advanced." Keene gave him a flat look.

"You're welcome to send your advice by carrier pigeon."

"Can Appraisal identify pigeons from photographs?" Patel laughed. Harris closed his eyes briefly. Keene pointed at Jack.

"This is why government writing has fewer jokes." Jack smiled. Then another thought surfaced. Emily. A little over a week ago, he had briefly considered whether her inevitable federal contact might someday become a bridge between GateGuide and the government. Apparently he had not needed one. That was probably better for everyone. Hannah was different. Hannah Reed was not part of this conversation. Not yet. One government secret at a time. Keene stepped onto the porch.

"You'll receive a written summary later today. It will include our current position regarding GateGuide, preliminary handling of the private Gate, and the pilot information-sharing proposal."

"Including the part where you're not ordering me to stop posting?"

"Yes."

"Good." Keene looked back at him.

"Mr. Mercer."

"Yeah?"

"We're going to ask again eventually."

"About what?"

"How you know as much as you do." Jack leaned against the doorframe.

"I assumed so."

"And?"

"I'll probably give you the same answer."

"Experience."

"Experience." She studied him for another moment. Then nodded.

"For now." The three of them walked toward the SUVs. Jack watched them leave. No raid. No seizure. No dramatic arrest. No secret prison. Just paperwork. Honestly, that was much closer to how governments usually worked. The email arrived three hours later. Jack was eating lunch. The subject line was painfully bureaucratic. FOLLOW-UP SUMMARY — MERCER / GATEGUIDE / PRIVATE GATE CONTACT He opened it. The first section confirmed his identity as the operator of GateGuide for the purpose of future federal contact.

The second stated, in much more legalistic language than Keene had used aloud, that no federal directive or request had been issued requiring him to cease independent operation of the account. Jack reread that paragraph twice.

"Good." Not permission. Better. A record. The private Gate section came next. Location subject to restricted federal handling pending further review. No immediate federal seizure action. No current federal emergency prohibition on Jack's own access. State and local authority expressly not addressed. Follow-up inspection to be scheduled with appropriately equipped personnel. Jack smiled slightly at the word appropriately. Apparently his lecture had survived into the memo.

Then came the proposed information-sharing arrangement. A limited pilot. Selected imagery and video. Personally identifying information removed where practical. Additional review for contextual identifiers before release. Requests for Appraisal or technical comment. No redistribution of restricted government material without authorization. Compensation structure to follow if the pilot became formal consulting. Designated point of contact: Rachel Keene. Jack saved the email in three places.

Fifteen years of adulthood had taught him many things. One was that government promises were substantially more useful when searchable. Then he noticed the attachment. Not one file. A folder link. PRIVATE GATE — SANITIZED INITIAL SAMPLE Jack stopped eating.

"That was fast." He opened it. Photographs loaded. A blue Gate inside a barn. Another behind a rural machine shed. One in the lower level of a concrete parking structure owned by a private company. A Gate between rows of trees on somebody's wooded acreage. One wedged absurdly between a backyard swimming pool and a privacy fence. Jack stared at that for several seconds.

"That's unfortunate." Next. Basement. Warehouse. Farm. Garage. Industrial lot. A handwritten note on one image read: OWNER REPORTS NO ENTRY. Another: LOCAL LAW ENFORCEMENT ENTERED APPROX. 20 FT. RETREATED. NO CONTACT. Another: PROPERTY OWNER REQUESTING ACCESS CLARIFICATION. Jack kept scrolling. There were more than enough. Not hundreds in the sample. Enough. Private Dungeons were not an edge case. They were already becoming a category. That meant registration. Insurance. Safety inspection. Commercial licensing.

Loot reporting. Minors. Emergency access. Privacy. Taxes. Neighbor complaints. Trespassing. Probably zoning. Definitely lawyers. Jack leaned back. Sixteen days after Dungeon Day One, the federal government had found GateGuide. GateGuide had acquired a government inbox. And Jack had just volunteered his backyard to help invent an entire regulatory category. He looked at the folder full of blue Gates appearing in barns, garages, warehouses, and basements across America.

"This is going to need a system."